I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Garlic Flavored Buttery Spray, 8 Fluid ounce, $4.99

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Garlic Spray, Eight oz. Bottle isn't just a must-have item for your kitchen, it's also what you yell pretty much every time you use it. And how fun is that? We'll tell you: a lot of fun. All it takes is just a few easy sprays to instantly add delicious buttery flavor to your favorite foods. Perfect for grilling meats and vegetables, adding a buttery crust to sandwiches or quesadillas, and making movie theater-style popcorn at home with zero calories per spray, I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! is the ultimate hack for leveling up your favorite recipes. Now go ahead and say the name again. Out loud. It feels great, pinky swear.

Country Crock Dairy Free Plant Butter with Olive Oil, 14 Ounce, $6.39

Bring plant-based goodness to the table with the Country Crock Dairy Free Plant Butter with Olive Oil, 14 oz Tub. This carefully crafted vegan and completely dairy free product is rich, creamy and oh so delicious! Made with delicious oils, it cooks and tastes like dairy butter! Enjoy it spreadable straight out of the fridge, ready for all your favorite foods. Each tablespoon contains 40% less saturated fat than a tablespoon of dairy butter, free from any artificial flavors, kosher certified and 100% gluten and dairy free. Simply swap Plant Butter 1:1 for dairy butter in any cooking recipe for one simple step towards eating more plant based! Brought to you by Country Crock, a brand committed to welcoming everyone to the table. We treat everyone like family here and every place like home. Our products are sustainably farmed and responsibly sourced. When you choose Country Crock Plant Butter, know that you’re helping the planet as this product produces less than half the greenhouse gas emissions than traditional dairy butter production. These can be swapped for butter in all of your favorite cooking recipes. Country Crock Plant Butter helps you easily start to experiment with decadent and fun plant based dishes in the kitchen - even the kids will love them!

Parkay Original Vegetable Oil Spread Sticks, 16 Ounce, $2.49

Parkay Vegetable Oil Spread Sticks have the same classic, creamy taste of butter, but in an easy-to-spread stick. Made with real nonfat milk for a fresh and creamy taste, Parkay sticks have 0 mg cholesterol per serving. With less calories per serving than butter, you can feel good about spreading Parkay Vegetable Oil Spread onto your favorite breads, muffins, vegetables, and more. Parkay Vegetable Oil Spread Sticks are easy to measure, making them great for baking and cooking your favorite recipes. Once you’ve had the rich, buttery taste of Parkay Margarine, you’ll never go back to butter.

Crystal Farms Spreadable Butter, with Canola Oil, Salted Sweet Cream, 8 Ounce, $2.79

Made in the Heartland from Midwest dairy, our spreadable Salted Sweet Cream Butter with Canola Oil is soft and spreadable, right out of the fridge. It tastes delectable on top of breads, veggies, pancakes and just about anything. Because we believe everything tastes better with our butter. Farm and Family are at the heart of everything Crystal Farms does, which is why we are on a mission to source 100% of our dairy products from the Midwest. With the purchase of our products, you’re joining with Crystal Farms in supporting farm families throughout the Heartland. Learn more at crystalfarmscheese.com.

Country Crock Calcium Buttery Spread Tub, 15 Ounce, $3.90

Bring authentic, country-fresh flavor to the table with Country Crock Calcium Buttery Spread Tub - 15 oz. This buttery spread gives you the rich, creamy, and delicious flavor you love, along with 8% daily value of calcium per 1 tbsp serving. Slow-churned in Kansas and carefully crafted with farm-grown ingredients, you can always count on Country Crock to be free of any artificial flavors and preservatives. There's a reason Country Crock has been a trusted favorite at the center of family tables for generations! Ready to use right out of the fridge, Country Crock Calcium Buttery Spread can be spread on top of your favorite breads and pastries for a deliciously decadent buttery treat. Use it as a secret ingredient to add depth of flavor and richness to your cooking and baking favorites from appetizers to main dishes, desserts, and more. Country Crock Calcium is free of gluten, hydrogenated oils, dairy, and lactose, has 0g cholesterol and trans fat per 1 tbsp serving, and has 75% less saturated fat than a 1 tbsp serving of traditional dairy butter. Brought to you by Country Crock, a brand committed to welcoming everyone to the table. We treat everyone like family and every place like home. Our products are sustainably farmed and responsibly sourced. When you can spread, top, cook and bake just about anything with this buttery spread, the options are endless with Country Crock!

Country Crock Calcium Buttery Spread Tub, 45 Ounce, $7.49

Bring authentic, country-fresh flavor to the table with Country Crock Calcium Buttery Spread Tub - 45 oz. This buttery spread gives you the rich, creamy, and delicious flavor you love, along with 8% daily value of calcium per 1 tbsp serving. Slow-churned in Kansas and carefully crafted with farm-grown ingredients, you can always count on Country Crock to be free of any artificial flavors and preservatives. There's a reason Country Crock has been a trusted favorite at the center of family tables for generations! Ready to use right out of the fridge, Country Crock Calcium Buttery Spread can be spread on top of your favorite breads and pastries for a deliciously decadent buttery treat. Use it as a secret ingredient to add depth of flavor and richness to your cooking and baking favorites from appetizers to main dishes, desserts, and more. Country Crock Calcium is free of gluten, hydrogenated oils, dairy, and lactose, has 0g cholesterol and trans fat per 1 tbsp serving, and has 75% less saturated fat than a 1 tbsp serving of traditional dairy butter. Brought to you by Country Crock, a brand committed to welcoming everyone to the table. We treat everyone like family and every place like home. Our products are sustainably farmed and responsibly sourced. When you can spread, top, cook and bake just about anything with this buttery spread, the options are endless with Country Crock!

Challenge Butter, Unsalted, 4 Each, $5.49

Butter, Unsalted

Kerrygold Irish Butter, 7.5 Ounce, $7.49

Imported. Milk from Irish grass-fed cows.

Benecol Buttery Spread, Light, 8 Ounce, $6.49

One serving of Benecol supplies 0.5 g of plant stanols. Per Serving (14 g): Benecol Light: 5 g total fat; 50 calories. 11 g margarine; 100 calories. 11 g butter; 100 calories. Gluten free. Half the calories and fat of butter (see nutritional information for fat content). 39% vegetable oils. With plant stanols (plant stanols are clinically proven to reduce cholesterol) (Foods containing at least 0.5 g per serving of plant stanols eaten with meals or snacks for a daily total intake of 2 g as part of a diet low in saturated fat and cholesterol, may reduce blood total cholesterol and the risk of heart disease). Tastes like butter, works like magic! www.BenecolUSA.com. For questions or comments, call toll free at 1-888-Benecol or visit www.BenecolUSA.com. $2 off. Visit www.benecolusa.com/signup and enter your email address! (1) coupon per email/ISP address. Sign up today and we will send you a $2.00 off (1) welcome coupon, along with recipes, usage ideas and money-saving offers.

Land O Lakes Fresh Buttery Taste Fresh Buttery Taste Spread, 15 Ounce, $4.19

Land O Lakes Fresh Buttery Taste Spread gives extra flavor to the food you love. Spread it onto warm dinner rolls or spoon it into a hot skillet and give your steak a sizzling golden crust. Stir it into vegetables, or melt it over a bowl of mashed potatoes. Land O Lakes Fresh Buttery Spread is made with quality ingredients. No matter how you use it, it will take your cooking to a whole new level. Land O Lakes Fresh Buttery Taste Spread: The name you know, a taste you'll love, the spreadability you expect. Contains one 15 oz tub in total.

Land O Lakes Salted Butter, Made with Sweet Cream and Salt, 1 Pound, $5.79

Whether melted, browned, creamed or clarified, Land O Lakes Salted Butter sticks improve the taste of everything they touch. Land O Lakes Salted Butter is made with two ingredients - sweet cream and salt. Delight your family and friends at spring brunch with the rich flavor of Land O Lakes Salted Butter. Use these four salted butter sticks in your favorite dinner recipes or to create delicious baked goods like muffins, pies, cookies and cakes. It's also ideal for making grilled cheese sandwiches with a golden, crispy edge. No matter how you use it, this stick butter will take your cooking to a whole new level. Land O Lakes Butter comes in pre-measured, ready-to-use butter sticks that are individually wrapped in a FlavorProtect wrapper to protect the flavor you love. You can enjoy these salted butter sticks knowing you are supporting farmer-owners in communities like yours all across the country. Contains 4 sticks, 1 lb. pack in total.

Land O Lakes Salted Whipped Butter, Spreadable, 8 Ounce, $4.19

Land O Lakes Salted Whipped Butter is made with quality ingredients and gives you the taste you love, spreadable right out of the fridge. Spread it onto warm, fluffy pancakes or spoon it into a hot skillet and give your steak a sizzling golden crust. Stir this delicious salted whipped butter into vegetables, or melt it over a bowl of mashed potatoes. No matter how you use it, it will take your cooking to a whole new level. You can enjoy it knowing you are supporting farmer-owners in communities across the country. Contains one 8 oz tub in total.

Land O Lakes Salted Extra Creamy Butter, European Style, 1 Pound, $5.99

Whether you’re making a creamy sauce, flaky breakfast pastries or just topping warm, fresh-baked bread, Land O Lakes Extra Creamy Butter adds that special touch when it matters. Made with sweet cream, this butter is 82% milkfat, which results in an amazing taste and raises the bar for baking. Land O Lakes Extra Creamy Butter is made with two ingredients: sweet cream and salt. Salted butter adds a layer of flavor when melted over fresh steamed veggies, gives pie crusts the perfect flakiness, and complements every grilled cheese with a golden, crispy edge. No matter how you use it, this stick butter will take your cooking to a whole new level. Land O Lakes Butter comes in pre-measured, ready-to-use butter sticks that are individually wrapped in our FlavorProtect wrapper to protect the flavor you love. You can enjoy these salted butter sticks knowing you are supporting farmer-owners in communities all across the country. Contains 4 sticks, 1 lb pack in total.

Smart Balance Omega-3 Buttery Spread, 15 Ounce, $4.99

Add delicious buttery goodness to all your favorite foods with Smart Balance Original Buttery Spread. This smooth, creamy spread is great on toast, muffins, vegetables and more. Smart Balance supports healthy cholesterol levels that are already in the normal range,* is gluten free, is an excellent source of vitamin D, contains 400 mg of omega-3 ALA and 33 mg of omega-3 EPA/DHA per serving and contains 60% less saturated fat than butter.** It's perfect for spreading, baking or cooking. Smart Balance: Spread the Goodness Everywhere. * When used as part of a healthy diet low in saturated fat and that includes exercise and other physical activity ** Butter has 7 g sat fat per serving. This product has 2.5 g sat fat per serving.

Land O Lakes Garlic & Herb Butter Spread, 6.5 Ounce, $3.29

Land O Lakes Garlic & Herb Butter Spread is packed with the bold flavors of garlic and herbs, and spreadable right out of the fridge. It provides the butter taste you love with the spreadable convenience you want, straight from the refrigerator and features a resealable top to maintain flavor. It's ideal for a quick, zesty garlic bread or for flavoring mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables. Land O Lakes Garlic & Herb Butter Spread is a secret weapon in the kitchen. No matter how you use it, it will take your cooking to a whole new level. Contains one 6.5 oz tub in total.

Smart Balance Buttery Spread, Light, with Flaxseed Oil, 15 Ounce, $4.99

38% vegetable oils. Supports healthy cholesterol levels (When used as part of a healthy diet low in saturated fat and that includes exercise and other physical activity) already in the normal range. See nutrition information for fat & sat fat content. 50% less fat & calories than butter or margarine (Smart Balance Light: 50 calories/5 g fat; Butter or Stick Margarine: 100 calories/11 g fat). Based on 1 Tbsp Serving Size: Smart Balance Light: 50 calories; 5 g total fat; 1.5 g sat fat; 0 g animal sat fat; 1.5 g plant-based sat fat; 0 mg cholesterol. Butter (When used as part of a healthy diet low in saturated fat and that includes exercise and other physical activity): 100 calories; 11 g total fat; 7 g sat fat; 7 g animal fat; 0 g plant-based sat fat; 30 mg cholesterol. Smart Move: Smart Balance Light is great for spreading; topping. 0 g Trans Fat: See nutrition information for fat & sat fat content. 75% Less Sat Fat than Butter: Butter 7 g sat fat per serv; this product 1.5 g sat fat per serv. Tastes great. Gluten free. Excellent Source of Omega-3 ALA: Contains 320 mg ALA per serv which is 20% of the 1.6 DV for ALA. 0 g trans fat. See nutrition information for fat & sat fat content. smartbalance.com. Clinical research has shown that the right blend of fats may improve your cholesterol ratio when at least 2/3 of your fat intake comes from this product or a properly balanced diet. Limit total fat to about 30% or calories (65 g per day); saturated fat to 10% of calories (20 g per day); and dietary cholesterol to 300 mg per day. Avoid trans fat. Regular exercise is essential. Visit: SmartBalance.com for great tips and recipes. Facebook. Twitter. Pinterest. how2recycle.info.

Vital Farms Grass-Fed Salted Butter, 2 Each, $4.39

Our mission at Vital Farms is to bring ethically produced food to the table. That’s why our grass-fed butter comes from grazing girls who are pasture-raised with care and respect on family farms. The cows have freedom to graze on open pastures during the warmer months. In turn, they supply a rich cream that’s churned into creamy, golden butter. We bet you can taste the difference!

Land O Lakes Honey Butter Spread, Spreadable, 6.5 Ounce, $3.29

Land O Lakes Honey Butter Spread transforms the ordinary into the extra special with a delicious honey flavor you'll love. It provides the butter taste you love with the spreadable convenience you want, straight from the refrigerator and features a resealable top to maintain flavor. Buttermilk biscuits, hot out of the oven, never had it so good. It's the perfect hint of sweetness for everything from melting into your morning oatmeal to tossing into steamed veggies. No matter how you use it, it will take your cooking to a whole new level. You can enjoy it knowing you are supporting farmer-owners in communities across the country. Contains one 6.5 oz tub in total.

Earth Balance Buttery Spread, Original, 15 Ounce, $6.69

Great rich taste. The taste you crave. The rich taste of this Earth Balance spread makes your favorite foods simply delicious. Our buttery spread will delight your taste buds and win your heart. Without the worry. Earth Balance original buttery spread is made with non-GMO ingredients and is free from hydrogenated oils. At Earth Balance, we believe that plant-based eating is a delicious way to enjoy food while respecting the planet. That's why all of our spreads are made from vegan ingredients, providing tasty alternatives that allow you to savor your favorite foods. Plant-based diet friendly. No MSG. Plant-based.

Essential Everyday Sweet Cream Salted Butter, 4 Each, $4.19

Sweet Cream Salted Butter

Country Crock Cinnamon Honey Spread Tub, 15 Ounce, $3.90

Bring authentic, country-fresh flavor to the table with Country Crock Cinnamon Honey Buttery Spread Tub - 15 oz. This buttery spread is rich, creamy, and delicious. Slow-churned in Kansas and carefully crafted with farm-grown ingredients, you can always count on Country Crock to be free of any artificial flavors and preservatives. There's a reason Country Crock has been a trusted favorite at the center of family tables for generations!

Land O Lakes Cinnamon Sugar Butter Spread, Spreadable, 6.5 Ounce, $3.29

Land O Lakes Cinnamon Sugar Butter Spread transforms the ordinary into the extra-special with a delicious cinnamon sugar flavor you'll love. It provides the butter taste you love with the spreadable convenience you want, straight from the refrigerator and features a resealable top to maintain flavor. Perfectly paired with classic toast, spread on a warm English muffin or French toast, or even stirred into hot cereal for an extra-special kiss of sweetness. No matter how you use it, it will take your cooking to a whole new level. You can enjoy it knowing you are supporting farmer-owners in communities across the country. Contains one 6.5 oz tub in total.

Amish Country Butter, Salted, Roll, 32 Ounce, $11.59

A gluten free product. Wisconsin grade A.

Country Crock Dairy Free Plant Butter with Avocado Oil, 14 Ounce, $6.19

Bring plant-based goodness to the table with the Country Crock Dairy Free Plant Butter with Avocado Oil, 14 oz Tub. This carefully crafted vegan and completely dairy free product is rich, creamy and oh so delicious! Made with delicious oils, it cooks and tastes like dairy butter! Enjoy it spreadable straight out of the fridge, ready for all your favorite foods. Each tablespoon contains 40% less saturated fat than a tablespoon of dairy butter, free from any artificial flavors, kosher certified and 100% gluten and dairy free. Simply swap Plant Butter 1:1 for dairy butter in any cooking recipe for one simple step towards eating more plant based! Brought to you by Country Crock, a brand committed to welcoming everyone to the table. We treat everyone like family here and every place like home. Our products are sustainably farmed and responsibly sourced. When you choose Country Crock Plant Butter, know that you’re helping the planet as this product produces less than half the greenhouse gas emissions than traditional dairy butter production. These can be swapped for butter in all of your favorite cooking recipes. Country Crock Plant Butter helps you easily start to experiment with decadent and fun plant based dishes in the kitchen - even the kids will love them!

Melt Organic Plant Butter, 13 Ounce, $6.39

Plant Butter

Country Crock Dairy Free Vegan Plant Butter with Olive Oil Sticks, 4 Each, $6.19

Bring plant-based goodness to the table with the Country Crock Plant Butter Sticks with Olive Oil, 16 oz, 4-pack. This carefully crafted vegan and dairy free product is rich, creamy and oh so delicious! Made with delicious oils, they bake, cook and taste like dairy butter! Enjoy it spreadable straight out of the fridge or store it for later in the freezer. Each tablespoon contains 25% less saturated fat than a tablespoon of dairy butter, is free from any artificial flavors, kosher certified and 100% gluten and dairy free. Simply swap Plant Butter 1:1 for dairy butter in any cooking or baking recipe for one simple and easy step towards eating more plant based! Brought to you by Country Crock, a brand committed to welcoming everyone to the table. We treat everyone like family here and every place like home. Our products are sustainably farmed and responsibly sourced. When you choose Country Crock Plant Butter, know that you’re helping the planet as production of this product results in less than half the greenhouse gas emissions of traditional dairy butter production. Country Crock Plant Butter helps you easily start to experiment with decadent and fun plant-based dishes in the kitchen - even the kids will love them!

Land O Lakes Unsalted Butter, Made with Sweet Cream, 1 Pound, $5.79

Precision is paramount when it comes to balancing flavors – whether it be in delicate cream puffs, fluffy cakes or tender sugar cookies. With Land O Lakes Unsalted Butter, you get the fresh, sweet cream taste you love and the flavor control you need when baking, cooking or topping. Make your springtime brunches extra special with Land O Lakes Unsalted Butter. Use these four unsalted butter sticks to create delicious baked goods like muffins, pies, cookies and cakes. It's also ideal for making grilled cheese sandwiches with a golden, crispy edge. No matter how you use it, this stick butter will take your cooking to a whole new level. Land O Lakes Butter comes in pre-measured, ready-to-use butter sticks that are individually wrapped in our FlavorProtect wrapper to protect the flavor you love. You can enjoy these unsalted butter sticks knowing you are supporting farmer-owners in communities across the country. Contains 4 sticks, 1 lb pack in total.

Crystal Farms Butter, Salted, Sweet Cream, 4 Each, $5.69

Made in the Heartland from Midwest dairy, our Salted Sweet Cream Butter is the perfect ingredient to add a little salty, savory flavor to your signature dish. Fits perfectly in, or on top of, literally anything. Because we believe everything tastes better with our butter. Farm and Family are at the heart of everything Crystal Farms does, which is why we are on a mission to source 100% of our dairy products from the Midwest. With the purchase of our products, you’re joining with Crystal Farms in supporting farm families throughout the Heartland. Learn more at crystalfarmscheese.com.

Kerrygold Butter, Pure Irish, 8 Ounce, $5.99

Milk from Irish grass-fed cows. Imported first quality. In Ireland, cows graze on the green pastures of small family farms. Their milk is churned to make Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter.

Kerrygold Butter, Pure Irish, 2 Each, $5.99

Milk from Irish grass-fed cows. Irish grass-fed cows. Imported: First quality. In Ireland, cows graze on the green pastures of small family farms. Their milk is churned to make Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter.