Cheddar (59)

Sartori Cheese, Old World Cheddar, Aged & Sharp, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Cheese, Old World Cheddar, Aged & Sharp

Wood River Creamery Cheese, Cheddar Gruyere, Natural, Semi-Hard, Original, 8 Ounce, $6.99

Cheese, Cheddar Gruyere, Natural, Semi-Hard, Original

Sartori Cheese, Smooth & Creamy, Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar, 5 Ounce, $6.99

Cheese, Smooth & Creamy, Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar

Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Farmhouse Cheddar

Hoffman's Cheese, Natural, White Vermont Cheddar, 7 Ounce, $5.49

Cheese, Natural, White Vermont Cheddar

Woodriver Creamery Alpine Style Cheddar Applewood Smoked, 8 Ounce, $6.99

Alpine Style Cheddar Applewood Smoked

Cabot Creamery Cheddar Cheese, Vermont, Sharp, 8 Ounce, $7.49

Cheddar Cheese, Vermont, Sharp

Kerrygold Cheese, Reserve, Cheddar, 7 Ounce, $8.49

Cheese, Reserve, Cheddar

Wood River Creamery Northwoods Cheddar, 8 Ounce, $6.99

Northwoods Cheddar

Hoffman's Cheese, Cheddar, 2 Year Aged, 7 Ounce, $5.49

Cheese, Cheddar, 2 Year Aged

Cabot Cheese, Vermont, Extra Sharp Cheddar, 8 Ounce, $7.49

Cheese, Vermont, Extra Sharp Cheddar

Cabot Creamery Cheddar Cheese, Vermont, Seriously Sharp, 8 Ounce, $7.49

Cheddar Cheese, Vermont, Seriously Sharp

Black Creek Cheddar Cheese with Gruyere Notes, 7 Ounce, $6.99

We're not afraid to get a little creative with our craft. This cheddar blend from Black Creek® cheese combines the bold bite of classic Cheddar with the nutty, earthy warmth of Gruyère—delivering a flavor combo that’s rich, smooth, and made for melting. It’s the kind of cheese that elevates soups, bakes like a dream, and pairs beautifully with a floral ale or fruity Riesling. This is cheddar that’s not afraid to show its cultured side. Made with milk from cows not treated with rBST*. *No significant difference has been shown between milk derived from rBST-treated and non-rBST-treated cows

Hoffman's Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $5.49

Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Great Midwest Cheddar Cheese, Cranberry, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Cheddar Cheese, Cranberry

Hoffman's Sweet Heat Habanero Cheese, 7 Ounce, $5.49

Sweet Heat Habanero Cheese

Great Midwest Cheese, Blueberry Cobbler Cheddar, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Give up the guilt and instead indulge in the creamy, fruity goodness of Great Midwest® Blueberry Cobbler Cheddar cheese. A generous serving of blueberries makes an appearance in every bite of this creamy white Cheddar. As delicious as a blueberry cheesecake without any of the guilt. Best eaten alone, as part of a fruit and cheese plate or topping off a delicious light lunch.

Cabot Creamery Cheddar Cheese, Wickedly Habanero, 8 Ounce, $7.49

Cheddar Cheese, Wickedly Habanero

Wood River Creamery Cheese, Cheddar Gruyere, Black Truffle, 8 Ounce, $6.99

Cheese, Cheddar Gruyere, Black Truffle

Hoffman's Smoky Hickory Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $5.49

Smoky Hickory Cheddar Cheese

Black Creek 3 Year Ultra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Aged for three full years by master cheesemakers in the heart of Wisconsin, this Ultra Sharp Cheddar delivers bold, layered flavor with a crumbly texture and a whole lot of character. It's the kind of cheese that earns its place on your board and steals the show in whatever dish you drop it into. Around here, we call that cheddar with conviction. Three years strong and full of the signature bite you expect from Black Creek® cheddar. Made with milk from cows not treated with rBST*. *No significant difference has been shown between milk derived from rBST-treated and non-rBST-treated cows

Tillamook Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar Cheese

Tillamook Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese

Kerrygold Dubliner Cheese, 100% Natural, 7 Ounce, $8.49

Cheese, 100% Natural

Milton Creamery Caramelized Cheddar, 6 Ounce, $6.99

Caramelized Cheddar

Great Midwest Cheese, Mango Fire Cheddar, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Oh, you sweet and spicy thing! Great Midwest® Mango Fire Cheddar cheese is anything but ordinary. Pump up the heat on your palate with delectable, sweet mango and bits of hot habanero pepper blended into smooth, firm Cheddar cheese. Perfect on dark rustic breads or grain crackers, enjoyed alone or with a dark icy beer.

Wood River Creamery Cheese, Gruyere, Cheddar, Roasted Red Pepper & Cracked Peppercorn, 8 Ounce, $6.99

Proudly Wisconsin Cheese. Hand-crafted since 1896. Small batches. Wisconsin master cheesemaker. Aged master cheesemaker. Flavor Profile: Classic, creamy, aged to perfection with savory spice & pleasant sweetness. Pairings: Pilsner or pale ale; merlot. No artificial growth hormones (No significant difference has been shown between milk from cows treated and not treated with rBST growth hormones). A unique fusion of cheddar and gruyere that melts indulgently and bakes to perfection. Use to accent any cheese tray or charcuterie platter, pairs well with a merlot, pilsner or pale ale. Crafted by farmer-owned.

Hoffman's Cheese, Ghost Pepper, 7 Ounce, $5.49

Cheese, Ghost Pepper

Red Apple Apple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, 8 Ounce, $7.99

Apple Smoked Cheddar Cheese

Yancey's Fancy Cheese, Bufflalo Wing Hot Sauce, New York Cheddar, 7.6 Ounce, $7.99

Pasteurized process. rBST free.

Old Croc Cheddar Cheese, Australian, Extra Sharp, 7 Ounce, $6.99

Born in the Land Down Under.